Stalin's War: A Radical New Theory of the Origins of the Second World War by Ernst Topitsch - PDF Download
Ernst Topitsch Stalins War Pdf Download
If you are interested in the history of World War II, you might have heard of Ernst Topitsch, a German philosopher and historian who wrote a controversial book called Stalin's War. In this book, Topitsch argues that Stalin was the main instigator and planner of World War II, and that he intended to use the war as a means to spread communism and conquer the world.
Ernst Topitsch Stalins War Pdf Download
Stalin's War was first published in German in 1985, and later translated into English in 1987. It caused a lot of debate and criticism among historians and scholars, who challenged Topitsch's sources, methods and conclusions. Some accused him of being a revisionist, a conspiracy theorist or even a Nazi sympathizer. Others praised him for being a courageous and original thinker who exposed Stalin's role and responsibility in World War II.
If you want to read Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch, you can download it as a PDF file from various websites. A PDF file is a document that preserves the layout and formatting of the original book. You will need a PDF reader, such as Adobe Acrobat Reader or Foxit Reader, to open and view the file.
To download Ernst Topitsch Stalins War Pdf, you will need to follow these steps:
Find a reliable website that offers the PDF file for Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch. You can use a search engine or a PDF site to look for it.
Download the PDF file to your computer. Make sure it is safe and virus-free.
Open the PDF file with your PDF reader. You can also print it or save it to another device.
Enjoy reading Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch and learn about his radical new theory of the origins of World War II.
That's it! You can now download Ernst Topitsch Stalins War Pdf and read this controversial and fascinating book.
What is the main argument of Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch?
Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch is a book that challenges the conventional view of World War II and its causes. Topitsch argues that Stalin was the main instigator and planner of World War II, and that he intended to use the war as a means to spread communism and conquer the world.
According to Topitsch, Stalin had a long-term strategy of provoking and manipulating the Western powers, especially Germany, into a war that would weaken them and allow him to intervene and dominate. Topitsch claims that Stalin used various tactics to achieve this goal, such as:
Supporting and financing communist parties and movements in Europe and Asia, especially in Germany, France, Spain and China.
Signing the Nazi-Soviet Pact in 1939, which gave him a free hand to invade Poland, Finland, the Baltic states and Romania.
Supplying Germany with raw materials and oil, while secretly preparing for an attack on Germany.
Encouraging Japan to attack the United States in 1941, hoping to create a two-front war for Germany.
Launching Operation Barbarossa in 1941, which was a preemptive strike by Hitler against Stalin's planned invasion of Germany.
Exploiting the Allied cooperation and aid during the war, while pursuing his own interests and agenda.
Topitsch argues that Stalin's war was not a defensive or ideological war, but a war of aggression and expansion. He also argues that Stalin's war was not inevitable or necessary, but a result of his personal ambition and paranoia. He claims that Stalin's war was the main cause of the Cold War and the division of Europe.
What are the sources and methods of Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch?
Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch is based on various sources and methods that Topitsch used to support his argument. Some of these sources and methods are:
Archival documents and memoirs from Soviet defectors and former officials, such as Viktor Suvorov, Pavel Sudoplatov and Nikita Khrushchev.
Military intelligence reports and diplomatic cables from Germany, Britain, France and the United States.
Historical analysis and comparison of Stalin's policies and actions with those of other dictators and leaders, such as Hitler, Mussolini, Mao Zedong and Napoleon.
Philosophical critique and interpretation of Stalin's ideology and worldview, based on his writings and speeches.
Topitsch claims that his sources and methods are reliable and objective, and that they reveal the truth about Stalin's war. However, his sources and methods have been criticized by many historians and scholars, who have questioned their validity, accuracy and relevance. Some of these criticisms are:
Some of his sources are biased or unreliable, such as Soviet defectors who had personal motives or agendas to discredit Stalin.
Some of his sources are incomplete or outdated, such as archival documents that have been declassified or revised since his book was published.
Some of his sources are irrelevant or misleading, such as military intelligence reports that were based on false or inaccurate information.
Some of his methods are flawed or questionable, such as historical analysis that ignores or distorts other factors or perspectives.
Some of his methods are speculative or subjective, such as philosophical critique that imposes his own views or assumptions on Stalin.
Topitsch's sources and methods have been challenged by many historians and scholars who have offered alternative explanations or interpretations of World War II and its causes.
What are the criticisms of Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch?
Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch is a book that has received a lot of criticisms from historians and scholars who have disputed his argument and evidence. Some of these criticisms are:
Topitsch ignores or downplays the role and responsibility of other actors and factors in World War II, such as Hitler, Nazi Germany, Japan, Italy, Britain, France and the United States.
Topitsch overestimates or exaggerates Stalin's power and influence in World War II, such as his ability to control or manipulate other countries, his military and economic resources, his intelligence and espionage network and his ideological appeal.
Topitsch underestimates or minimizes Stalin's challenges and difficulties in World War II, such as his internal problems and opposition, his external threats and enemies, his strategic and tactical mistakes and his human and material losses.
Topitsch misinterprets or distorts Stalin's motives and goals in World War II, such as his defensive or pragmatic reasons, his national or regional interests, his ideological or political compromises and his historical or cultural influences.
Topitsch lacks or fails to provide sufficient or convincing evidence or proof for his claims and accusations, such as direct or indirect documents, testimonies or witnesses, logical or causal connections or explanations.
Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch is a book that has been challenged by many historians and scholars who have offered alternative explanations or interpretations of World War II and its causes.
What is the impact of Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch?
Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch is a book that has had a significant impact on the debate and research on World War II and its causes. Topitsch's book has provoked a lot of reactions and responses from historians and scholars, as well as from the general public and the media.
Some of the impacts of Stalin's War by Ernst Topitsch are:
It has challenged the conventional view of World War II and its causes, which usually focuses on Hitler's aggressions and ambitions, and has offered a radical new theory that puts Stalin at the center of the conflict.
It has stimulated further investigation and discussion on Stalin's role and responsibility in World War II, as well as on his motives and goals, his policies and actions, his power and influence, his challenges and difficulties, and his sources and methods.